The proposed sale of IDBI Bank to Canada-based Fairfax Financial has triggered a debate over whether the bank was valued fairly before the stake sale. The government approved the sale of a 60.72% stake in IDBI Bank to Fairfax at ₹81 per share, valuing the transaction at around ₹52,878 crore.
Questions emerged after reports highlighted an internal note suggesting that the first round of bids was below the earlier reserve price of ₹94.42 per share. Later, valuation methods were reviewed and a revised benchmark of ₹75.99 per share was arrived at. Fairfax subsequently improved its offer to ₹81 per share, which was higher than the revised valuation benchmark.
Critics argue that changing valuation parameters after the initial bidding process may have lowered the benchmark and benefited the buyer. They believe the original reserve price reflected a stronger valuation of the bank.
However, the Department of Investment and Public Asset Management (DIPAM) has defended the process. It said the valuation review was conducted under powers granted to the Core Group of Secretaries on Disinvestment and that independent valuers reassessed the bank using updated financial data. According to DIPAM, the process remained fair and bidders had no access to valuation details.
The controversy is not about whether IDBI Bank should be sold, but whether the valuation process ensured the best possible price for public assets. The debate is likely to continue as stakeholders examine the deal closely.



